Public track record
Storyline Scoreboard
Fans swear some games mean more: a player facing his old team, a homecoming, something to prove. We tag those games before kickoff, then check whether those players beat their projections by more than everyone else. Whatever it finds goes here, win or lose. All scoring is PPR.
Revenge games
A player facing a team he played for: at least four games there in the last three seasons, or any this season.
No clear effect yet: slightly worse than their peers on average, but well inside what luck alone produces.
Games graded
43
15 more tagged but didn't play
Beat projection
37%
everyone else: 41%
Vs projection
−0.1 pts
comparable players: +0.8 pts
The storyline effect
−0.9 pts
rough range −2.5 to +0.8
Every graded game
- Charlie Kolar TE · LAC · Week 10 · Faces BAL, his team through 2025proj 2.7 → 3.6+0.4 vs peers
- Keaton Mitchell RB · LAC · Week 10 · Faces BAL, his team through 2025proj 2.8 → 0.4−3.2 vs peers
- Dareke Young WR · LV · Week 10 · Faces SEA, his team in 2024 and 2025proj 0.1 → 0.0−1.9 vs peers
- Cody White WR · LV · Week 10 · Faces SEA, his team in 2025proj 1.3 → 3.2+0.1 vs peers
- Calvin Ridley WR · TEN · Week 10 · Faces JAX, his team through 2023proj 1.5 → 0.0−3.3 vs peers
- Nick Westbrook-Ikhine WR · IND · Week 10 · Faces MIA, his team in 2025proj 0.7 → 0.0−2.5 vs peers
- Aaron Jones RB · MIN · Week 10 · Faces GB, his team through 2023proj 7.3 → 12.5+2.3 vs peers
- Joshua Dobbs QB · DET · Week 10 · Faces NE, his team in 2025proj 4.7 → 0.1−6.3 vs peers
- Tyler Goodson RB · DAL · Week 9 · Faces IND, his team through 2025proj 2.9 → 7.7+3.7 vs peers
- Justin Fields QB · KC · Week 9 · Faces NYJ, his team in 2025proj 10.1 → -2.1−11.9 vs peers
- Audric Estime RB · NO · Week 9 · Faces CLE, his team earlier this seasonproj 5.0 → 14.7+9.2 vs peers
- Saquon Barkley RB · PHI · Week 9 · Faces NYG, his team through 2023proj 10.0 → 8.2+1.5 vs peers
- Van Jefferson WR · WAS · Week 9 · Faces LA, his team through 2023proj 1.7 → 16.8+13.4 vs peers
- David Sills WR · TB · Week 8 · Faces ATL, his team in 2025proj 0.6 → 0.0−1.3 vs peers
- Ameer Abdullah RB · JAX · Week 8 · Faces IND, his team in 2025proj 0.6 → 1.3−0.6 vs peers
- Geno Smith QB · NYJ · Week 8 · Faces LV, his team in 2025proj 13.9 → 18.0+4.9 vs peers
- Ryan Miller WR · NE · Week 8 · Faces MIA, his team earlier this seasonproj 0.5 → 0.0−1.2 vs peers
- Kenneth Walker III RB · KC · Week 7 · Faces SEA, his team through 2025proj 22.4 → 9.7−11.9 vs peers
- David Moore WR · CAR · Week 7 · Faces TB, his team through 2023proj 0.8 → 0.0−1.3 vs peers
- Charlie Woerner TE · ATL · Week 7 · Faces SF, his team through 2023proj 0.3 → 2.2+0.5 vs peers
- Alex Bachman WR · LA · Week 7 · Faces LV, his team in 2024 and 2025proj 0.0 → 0.0−0.5 vs peers
- Devin Singletary RB · NYG · Week 7 · Faces HOU, his team through 2023proj 1.9 → 14.5+11.0 vs peers
- John Metchie III WR · CAR · Week 6 · Faces PHI, his team in 2025proj 2.7 → 4.4+1.0 vs peers
- Kenny Gainwell RB · TB · Week 6 · Faces PIT, his team in 2025proj 7.3 → 3.4−5.4 vs peers
- Olamide Zaccheaus WR · ATL · Week 6 · Faces CHI, his team in 2025proj 3.8 → 0.0−4.5 vs peers
- Tylan Wallace WR · CLE · Week 6 · Faces BAL, his team through 2025proj 0.4 → 2.2+1.1 vs peers
- Jameis Winston QB · NYG · Week 6 · Faces NO, his team through 2023proj 12.8 → 6.5−7.4 vs peers
- Eric Saubert TE · SEA · Week 5 · Faces SF, his team in 2024proj 1.0 → 0.0−1.6 vs peers
- Johnny Mundt TE · PHI · Week 5 · Faces JAX, his team in 2025proj 0.8 → 0.0−1.4 vs peers
- Joshua Dobbs QB · DET · Week 5 · Faces ARI, his team through 2023proj 0.3 → 0.0−2.7 vs peers
- Sam Darnold QB · SEA · Week 5 · Faces SF, his team through 2023proj 14.4 → 8.3−5.6 vs peers
- J.K. Dobbins RB · DEN · Week 5 · Faces LAC, his team in 2024proj 7.9 → 15.4+8.4 vs peers
- Malachi Corley WR · CLE · Week 5 · Faces NYJ, his team in 2024proj 0.5 → 0.0−1.6 vs peers
- Reggie Gilliam RB · NE · Week 4 · Faces BUF, his team through 2025proj 0.5 → 0.0−0.7 vs peers
- Mack Hollins WR · NE · Week 4 · Faces BUF, his team in 2024proj 7.0 → 8.3−1.3 vs peers
- Derrick Henry RB · BAL · Week 4 · Faces TEN, his team through 2023proj 19.9 → 15.9−5.2 vs peers
- Josh Palmer WR · BUF · Week 3 · Faces LAC, his team through 2024proj 6.3 → 0.0−6.4 vs peers
- Wan'Dale Robinson WR · TEN · Week 3 · Faces NYG, his team through 2025proj 10.2 → 18.7+7.1 vs peers
- Daniel Bellinger TE · TEN · Week 3 · Faces NYG, his team through 2025proj 2.9 → 3.6+1.3 vs peers
- Marquez Valdes-Scantling WR · LAC · Week 3 · Faces BUF, his team in 2024proj 2.8 → 0.0−3.3 vs peers
- Ke'Shawn Williams WR · CIN · Week 3 · Faces PIT, his team in 2025proj 0.2 → 0.0−0.7 vs peers
- D'Andre Swift RB · CHI · Week 3 · Faces PHI, his team through 2023proj 15.7 → 10.8−6.9 vs peers
- Kendrick Bourne WR · ARI · Week 3 · Faces SF, his team in 2025proj 7.0 → 4.2−2.9 vs peers
Tagged but didn't play (not counted): Brandin Cooks (week 10), Velus Jones Jr. (week 8), AJ Dillon (week 8), Joshua Dobbs (week 8), Brian Robinson (week 7), Joe Milton III (week 7), AJ Dillon (week 6), Kenny Pickett (week 6), Deebo Samuel Sr. (week 6), Kylen Granson (week 6), Marquez Valdes-Scantling (week 6), Jake Haener (week 6), Cooper Rush (week 5), Chris Moore (week 4), Tyler Conklin (week 3).
Tagged for the games ahead
Tagged from our data before kickoff and frozen once the game starts. Projections are StatGrades' PPR projections, frozen the same way.
- Tony Pollard RB · TEN · Week 11 · Faces DAL, his team through 2023proj 18.5Ask about it
- Jordan Mason RB · MIN · Week 11 · Faces SF, his team through 2024proj 6.4Ask about it
- Jauan Jennings WR · MIN · Week 11 · Faces SF, his team through 2025proj 2.2Ask about it
- Joe Milton III QB · PHI · Week 12 · Faces DAL, his team in 2025proj 13.3Ask about it
- Kalif Raymond WR · CHI · Week 12 · Faces DET, his team through 2025proj 6.9Ask about it
- DeAndre Carter WR · DET · Week 12 · Faces CHI, his team in 2024proj 0.0Ask about it
How this works
Nothing is picked afterwards. Each storyline is tagged from our data before the game (who played for which team, from three seasons of play-by-play records), and each projection is frozen before kickoff. Neither is changed once the game starts.
Beating a projection isn't enough. In some weeks nearly everyone beats it, and a 4-point backup misses differently from a 20-point starter. So every tagged player is compared with untagged players at his position, in the same week, with a similar projection. The storyline effect is how much better (or worse) he did than they did.
Small samples lie. A dozen games can swing either way by luck, so the range under the effect shows roughly how far chance alone could move it. Until at least 20 games are in, the verdict says it's too early. When the range sits entirely above or below zero, that's a real finding.
What's tagged so far: revenge games. Homecomings would need birthplaces, which our data doesn't have yet; Ask StatGrades finds those stories in the news instead. See also the projection scorecard. Tagging started in week 3 of 2026.